Working copy
Draft text, rebuilt from the manuscript on every change. Stubs and source passages are still here, and none of it is final. Back to the working copy contents
Ready to read This chapter is published on the home page.
Prologue
The Stevenson Test says that New Nature is wherever there is nobody to appeal to. Civilizations are the product of world machines humanity has built to generate systems for appeals.
Venkatesh Rao, Aneesh Sathe and SIGPSY (the Special Interest Group in Psychohistory), with the World Machines and Prime Radiant projects, have been mapping out humanity's recent efforts. Rao calls the result New Nature: laws made by technology that are nearly as hard to appeal as nature's own, and AI is the newest and wildest of them. In this jungle, a small sliver of light fell onto my industry, left behind on the forest floor as tech-based businesses reached for the sky.
Along with agriculture, construction has concerned itself with providing the physical backing needed to drive the creation of increasingly complex machines. Unlike agriculture, which provides uncertain outputs that are easy for outsiders to measure, construction has been plagued since the days of Hammurabi by its need to provide certain outcomes that are hard for the non-builder to evaluate. The Babylonians resolved the issue with the simplest solution: strict liability for the builder. The homeowner could appeal for the builder to be liable for all damages; the builder could not appeal.
While our society's lack of appetite for murdering the sons of general contractors in eye-for-an-eye legal remedies is welcomed by construction workers and their families, moving away from the Mesopotamian solution to the principal-agent problem has required a far more complex framework.
These days the tension is distributed through multiple protocols: training, certification, inspection, licensing, engineering, claims, and contracts. This system for resolving appeals and counterappeals has developed over thousands of years and, in common law jurisdictions, resists New Nature through a single legal fiction: the reasonable person. [b]
The Gramsci monster in our story, the one that spawns in the time between machines, is the reasonable bot.
The current tech stack allows AI bots to design buildings, write specifications, read specifications, and bid on requirements. They may not be able to do this well, but the tech keeps improving. When it reaches parity with human estimators, the challenge will come not from calculations but from liability. How could the productivity gains from the automation of the administrative portions of construction procurement be realized if humans must always review the work of bots?
For long-time followers of the Protocol Institute, the answer may have been obvious: standardization. For those who, like me, needed to take the long route, a mini-Prime Radiant project focused on Bot Procurement may be needed to arrive at the same answer: Procurement Machines.
AI-first procurement will need two tools: documents written for machines to read, and a standardized bot to read them. With these tools, engineers and architects could still certify the canonical copy, the court could use the standardized bot as a surrogate for a reasonable bot, and bidders would be able to lower their estimating costs. [d]
Two names will travel through this book, and they are worth keeping apart. Bot Construction is the field: where this work leads, from documents written for machines to robots on site, built on everything the trades have already built. Bot Procurement is the standard: the price on a tender and who is liable when a bot gets it wrong, a part kept small enough to test. Bot Construction is where we are going. Bot Procurement is what has to be earned first.